One of the forums I browse had a thread recently "Warhammer Fantasy - What Went Wrong?"
I thought that it might be an interesting read to get some differing perspectives. Regular readers will know that I love the Warhammer 8th Ed rule set finding it far more balanced than its predecessor. This is especially so as the cycle of Warhammer Army Books has progressed.
One of the main reasons is that the game has IMO become one of risk management rather than spatial awareness. While a lot of critics decry it as randomhammer there are a fair percentage who remember 7th WHFB as the "carpentry edition" (all angles and micro-measurement).
So reading through the thread I quickly realised that a lot of the commentators either hadn't played 8th or "tried one game and it wasn't for me". The forum is primarily US based and, apart from Australia, that appears to be the centre of anti-8th feeling. Not all of the USA - because in essence it is a series of countries wargaming wise, but significant pockets.
A common refrain was that things like random charge distances take the skill out of the game. Again IMO this is so far from the truth that you really struggle to give credence to their other observations. It takes different skills - you need to be able to risk weight outcomes and determine whether you need a credible Plan B in the event you upset the dice gods!
Now I'm not saying 8th is without fault but army balance relative is not one of them. People seem to forget the troika of Vamps, Daemons and Dark Elves that dominated 7th ed events. They forget the UKGTs with three identical lists (give or take one unit) dominating the top 25 tables. The tournament game required far more comp than it does now - pre ET (where we are seeing some old probs resurface).
What I'm not sure is how people who haven't played the game can say that another version was better. Sure, you can say the current version isn't to your liking or that you preferred the other but that is subjective rather than objective. I know in my case I never really played 5th, 6th or 7th 40k. As such I have no idea if they were better than 4th and could never make an objective assessment as to which is the better game.
Anyway I found it amusing to read long dissertations on what was wrong with the game - stated as fact - and then find that they were backed by little or no objective experience. Us humans are funny animals.